
A High Court judge has dismissed a claim that Betfair failed in its duty of care to a customer who took their own life in 2021.
The Flutter Entertainment-owned brand was questioned in a court case that began in June about whether it failed to identify Luke Ashton’s gambling addiction and intervene before he committed suicide.
The claim was brought by Mr Ashton’s widow Annie Ashton and his family, following a 2023 coroner’s inquest which concluded Betfair had failed to step in after Mr Ashton’s gambling habits had increased. Betfair denied the claims.
Handing down his verdict on the case, Judge Jonathan Swift ruled Betfair could not have been able to conclusively rule that Ashton had a gambling disorder. Swift wrote in his ruling: “The duty of care the claimants contend for did not arise on the facts of this case. The possibility of such injury would be foreseeable if the defendant had known or ought to have realised that Mr Ashton suffered from either mild or moderate gambling disorder.
“However, the claimants fail on the foreseeability issue. There is no sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that Mr Ashton did suffer from gambling disorder and that being so, no possible basis on which the requirement for foreseeability could be met. The claimants’ case therefore fails, and is dismissed.”
The court heard how Mr Ashton, who was 40 at the time of his death, had gambled online since 2009, and had online accounts with a number of operators. The amounts he deposited in the accounts varied year to year, but from 2016, he deposited substantial amounts, rising from £2,600 in 2016 to £15,000 in 2020.
Mr Ashton went missing on April 21, 2021 and was found dead the next day; he had left messages for his wife and children. In one of the messages left to his wife, he said his “mental health [was] all over the place”. He referred to having “demons in [his head]” and said “gambling was just the straw that broke the camel’s back”.
Mr Ashton’s family claimed the data available to Betfair should have informed the operator about his betting activity, and that its obligation to prevent harm stemmed from its “knowledge that gambling can cause psychiatric harm and the particular risks of harm arising from exchange betting”. From 2019 to 2021, Mr Ashton gambled almost exclusively via the Betfair exchange.
The family sued TSE Malta, the holding company for Flutter which owns the Betfair, Paddy Power and Sportsbet brands. Reacting to the verdict, a Flutter UKI spokesperson said: "While we welcome the court's ruling, this is a tragic case and we once again offer our sincere condolences to Mrs Ashton and her family.”
Mr Ashton’s prevention of future deaths report mentioned he had a gambling disorder from at least 2019 and that this contributed to his decision to end his own life. The coroner mentioned how Mr Ashton had attempted to use self-exclusion tools, but the only contact he had received from Betfair was emails informing him about these tools that could be accessed.
British regulator the Gambling Commission was sent a copy of the inquest, but the British regulator decided in February 2025 not to take any further action against Betfair. Mrs Ashton also filed a separate claim for a judicial review of the Commission in February last year, deciding to challenge the Commission’s ruling.

+18 | Please gamble responsibly | Commercial content | T&Cs apply GambleAware.com